-
How Do You Handle No Rental History for FHA or VA Buyers?
Hi Everyone.
What are the options when a borrower has no recent rental history? For example, let’s say someone has been living in hotels for the past year, or maybe they were staying with family or friends and didn’t have rent in their name.
If the borrower has decent income, good DTI, and a low credit score around 590, how do you approach this for VA or FHA loans? Especially in cases where manual underwriting might be needed.
Can hotel stays be documented as housing history? And if they were staying with a relative, is a letter from the homeowner or utility bills in the homeowner’s name usually accepted?
Just looking to hear how others are handling these situations. Appreciate any input.
-
This discussion was modified 12 hours, 53 minutes ago by
Chad Bush.
-
This discussion was modified 12 hours, 53 minutes ago by
-
2 Replies
-
Finding a VA or FHA mortgage can feel like a brick wall when you don’t show any recent rent payments, yet the loan process still offers a way through. Plenty of lenders use manual underwriting to open that door for someone living in a hotel or bouncing among relatives.
A borrower with a steady income, a DTI under 43 percent, and a credit score of around 590 already carries some weight. The key now is gathering alternative proofs of stability and being ready to explain the housing gap in plain terms.
VA Loans: Options and Considerations
VA home loans pack some serious advantages, and one of the biggest is the relaxed credit rules from the Department of Veterans Affairs. While the agency itself won’t lock in a rock-solid credit floor, most lenders lean on a 580-to-620 sweet spot, meaning you’ll still run into a minimum score at the bank counter. Suppose your number lands around 590, and your pay stubs back it up. In that case, the debt-to-income ratio stays near 41 or 42, so you could clear the gate even if the crew has to bump a few buttons for manual underwriting. Do you have any landlord receipts? No problem, they’ll say, once you show them your paycheck and the bills that show where the money goes.
No Recent Rental History (Hotel Stays or Living with Family/Friends)VAs Flexibility with Non-Traditional Credit:
When the file appears thin, the VA lets lenders study other proof that you send money on time, whether that’s the power bill, the cell phone plan, or the streaming queue you probably can’t live without. Those ledger drops tell the underwriter, “Yeah, this person knows how to pay.” The upside is big because a missing rent book won’t tank the whole deal as long as the supports show a pattern.
Hotel Stays as Housing History:
Hotel bills, however, get weird. They follow day-to-day rates and lack a formal lease signature so that most shops won’t consider rent history. Because of that, reserving a corner room every month could count more toward travel perks than mortgage approval.
When a borrower is under manual underwriting, a lender sometimes looks beyond the standard papers. Believe it or not, regular hotel receipts, credit card charges, or bank statement lines showing steady room payments can prove that the borrower has been keeping a roof over their head at the lender’s call. The VA handbook never spells this out, so it stays in the gray zone.
Living with Family or Friends
If a service member crashed on a sibling’s couch rent-free, the VA will not chase a Verification of Rent. One-line letters from the kinfolk, plus older bills like power or phone statements in the borrower’s name, usually clear that hurdle pretty quietly. (Gustan Cho Associates has a walkthrough on when VOR is needed, and his site also tracks FHA’s manual underwriting quirks.)
Manual Underwriting for VA Loans
Credit scores that sink below 620 or debt ratios that creep too high almost always push the file toward manual review. The same holds for borrowers who build credit in the old-fashioned way instead of with shiny FICO numbers.
Compensating Factors
Lenders do not just wave the file goodbye; they start hunting offsets or what the industry calls compensating factors. Residual income tops that list. It gauges the cash left after the proposed mortgage, existing debts, and utilities have taken their share.
According to several veteran-focused portals, a borrower with a few hundred dollars in breathing room every month and a chunky DTI may sail right through.
Cash Reserves:
Think of keeping enough cash to cover your mortgage for three to six months. That cushion can make underwriters nod yes when they weigh your application. Even though the number sounds big, it works like a seatbelt- just there to keep you safe.
Stable Employment:
Sticking with the same employer, or at least staying in the same field, for a couple of solid years sends a message that your paycheck isn’t sprinting off somewhere. Underwriters like that predictability almost as much as they like the paperwork.
Manual Review:
When the machine stops humming, a human gets your file. Bills, pay stubs, credit card habits, and even old rent checks end up on the table when that lender asks, Will this borrower be able to pay in month number 12?
Housing History Proof:
Lenders want a trail they can follow. A dozen hotel invoices pasted together does the trick, though some banks will still shrug and call it flimsy. The easiest way to leave no doubt is to have those charges appear on a debit or credit card statement year after year.
Landlord Letter:
A low-tech option is a handwritten note from Grandma saying, “Yes, Johnny lived here rent-free, and I paid for the lights.” Toss in one of his old utility bills, a joint bank entry, or even the same address on a driver’s license, and you have a tidy story even the sticklers can accept.
Build Credit with Everyday Bills
Veterans sometimes run into house-hunting hurdles when traditional credit files look thin.
One fast workaround is to use alternative tradelines. The idea is simple: track a full year’s on-time utility, cell phone, or auto insurance payments.
Most lenders want 12 months of history showing you paid each bill. When those statements land in the mortgage file, they beef up the applicant’s non-traditional credit picture.
Lender Overlays and the Value of Comparison Shopping
VA home loans come with standard rules, yet every lender seems to write a few extras labeled overlays. Some shops insist on a minimum Vantage score of 620; others drop the bar to 580 if alternative credit is included.
A direct quote from the GCA Mortgage Group states that no two lenders apply the VA loan guidelines similarly. That means one borrower can walk in with a 590 score and be told yes in one office while hearing no down the hall.
Specialized outfits like FHA Bad Credit Lenders or Non-QM Mortgage Lenders are worth dialing first. Their teams deal with manual underwrites daily and know how to smooth out odd situations. More details are available at their respective sites.
Watch Out for Payment Shock
Payment shock is the phrase underwriting boards use to measure how much a monthly mortgage will jolt a borrower. Someone moving from free room-and-board to a $1,700 PITI bill can face serious sticker shock.
Strong residual income or a chunky cash cushion becomes job one when that happens. Funds inside savings, checking, or retirement accounts help prove the applicant won’t drown after closing day.
Score Slim? Fix It Fast
A 590 credit number sounds close to the line, yet even small tweaks can elevate an application. Paying credit card balances below 30 percent and mailing bills on time make an instant difference. These easy habits push the score higher before the lender even looks.
Mortgage pros recommend repeating the basics each month. Over time, the steady habits reduce anxiety and strengthen the case for approval.
FHA Loans: A Common-Sense Backup
If you ship the same application to an FHA lender, the picture stays rosy. That program allows borrowers with a score under 580 to wiggle into a mortgage by putting down 10 percent instead of 3.5. For many first-timers, the alternative feels like breathing room during a hectic move.
FHA loans have tighter rules regarding rental history checks, especially if a lender uses manual underwriting.
VOR Requirement Explained
When a borrower has little or no traditional credit and the file goes manual, the FHA still wants proof of 12 months’ rent. That paper trail must show the money changed hands every month; without it, the deal stalls.
Living in a Hotel
Some people bounce between hotels while job-hunting or relocating. Bank statements and front-desk receipts can prove those nightly fees, yet most lenders shrug them off because a hotel stay lacks a long-term lease.
Crash at a Friend’s House
Sleeping on a buddy’s sofa? FHA guidelines allow a simple letter from the homeowner saying no rent was paid, so long as the dates line up and the note is signed. You can skip that letter, and the rent demand will increase.
Utility bills reaching the homeowner’s mailbox can back up a residency claim. However, they fall short of verifying rent unless the borrower’s name is printed on the statement.
FHA loans can slip into manual underwriting territory when a person’s debt-to-income ratio jumps past 43 percent. The same route opens up if credit sinks below 620 or the file is so thin that a score hardly shows. Those sitting at 590 may see nothing but a manual review.
Compensating factors soften the blow of a low score or sketchy rental history. An underwriter first looks for reserves: three full months of mortgage cash tucked away for one- to two-unit homes and six months for properties with three or four units.
Payment shock, the bite a borrower feels when moving into a new mortgage, must stay small. The target is a rise of less than $100 or a jump of just 5 percent, which is hard to hit if the applicant has never paid a rent bill.
Solid past-rent payments can tip the scale if the buyer has them. The rule of thumb is 12 straight months showing on-time remittances.
Residual income also matters, borrowing page after page from HUD’s guidelines. The borrower must have money left after bills, taxes, and the mortgage vanish from the ledger.
Stable work helps round out the picture. Two or more consecutive years in the same job or at least the same field gives the reviewer some peace of mind.
- When you apply for a mortgage, the underwriter closely examines how steady your paycheck is.
- They’ll also peek at anything showing you pay on time, like utility bills or the cellphone tab.
- If you have notes showing rent or other housing costs, those go in the mix, too.
- Staying on the road for work?
- The lender sometimes accepts year-long hotel receipts as proof of where you lived.
- Most lenders won’t count that alone as a Verified Residency form, so call around and ask what each FHA shop will allow.
- If you live free, a quick letter from a friend or family member letting you crash works well.
- It must name them, give out the address, and say how long you were there.
- Utility statements that show their name help, but they don’t replace the written note unless your name is on the bill.
- Online bills, car insurance, and even the Netflix fee can stand in when conventional credit isn’t an option.
- Gather a dozen months, make sure everyone is paid on time, and then print or export the file’s history.
– Prices and rules can shift from one FHA lender to the next, a quirk called an overlay. Some shops still demand a 620 score, even if HUD says 580 is fine, or insist on a written residency note, no matter your score. Shopping around and paying attention to teams like Gustan Cho Associates that know manual files inside can save headaches and dollars.
Other Considerations: Down Payment:
Borrowers with a 590 score will need a 3.5 percent down payment. Could you ensure they have money for that and the closing costs?
Credit Improvement
Paying off credit cards can push utilization below 30 percent and may lift the score. A higher score usually means easier approvals. Gustan Cho Associates has a full write-up on the idea.
Key Differences Between VA and FHA Loans in This Scenario: Credit Score Flexibility
VA sets no hard minimum score, although most lenders want 580 to 620. FHA sticks to 580 for the 3.5 percent down requirement. A score of 590 works for both, yet VA is likely to bend more for someone with shaky or older credit.
VOR Requirements
FHA insists on a written Verification of Rent or a special waiver to make the rules feel strict. VA lenders often skip the VOR if other proof of payments exists, giving them more room to maneuver. Gustan Cho Associates has extra notes on when that paperwork matters.
Down Payment
VA buyers can close the deal with zero down, an obvious win if savings are light. FHA borrowers must come up with that 3.5 percent, which can stall things at the last minute.
Mortgage Insurance:
FHA loans impose an upfront premium and an annual MIP that stretch the budget. VA loans avoid monthly mortgage insurance but charge a funding fee; the neat part is that the fee can be rolled into the mortgage balance. For more information, please review Gustan Cho Associates’ explanation of fees and long-term costs.
Practical Steps for Handling Tough Loan Situations
Find a VA- or FHA-savvy lender. Could you contact companies specializing in VA or FHA financing for borrowers with offbeat credit stories? Groups like Veterans United or Gustan Cho Associates often do manual underwriting. They will take alternative proof instead of the usual score, which can save a deal that bigger banks would toss.
Save Your Paper Trail
If you stayed in a hotel and paid month after month, hang on to a year of receipts or bank statements. Under manual underwriting, those records can double as a Verbal Verification of Rent, even if they don’t fit the mold.
Living Rent-Free?
Ask the family member or friend who owns the house for a simple letter confirming you paid no rent. Toss in utility bills or bank files with your name to back up what the owner says.
Alternative Credit Works
Most services- report cards- are like pay stubs, and lenders know it. Collect a year’s on-time bills for light, phone, and insurance. If nothing is late, you’re halfway to proving you can handle a mortgage.
Highlight Compensating Factors
Borrowers shouldn’t overlook the reassuring details tucked into their pay stubs. A strong salary, low debt-to-income ratio, cash reserves, and years of steady work can calm even the strictest underwriters. FHA insiders often expect three months of mortgage payments sitting in the bank. VA pros look for leftover money that clears the required residual income bar. ꟷ
Improve the Credit Profile
Raising a credit score often boils down to small habits, not magic. Keeping credit card balances below 30 percent and paying every bill on time gives the FICO algorithm a friendly nudge before the application hits the desk. ꟷ
Shop Around
No one lender writes the same rulebook. A borrower who collects quotes from three or five mortgage shops can usually spot the few that forgive low scores and quirky rental histories. ꟷ
Additional Tips: Mortgage Broker.
A good broker knows the market’s nooks and crannies and can steer clients toward lenders specializing in low credit.
Credit Counseling
If numbers stay stubborn, a certified credit counselor will develop a step-by-step game plan for improvement.
Pre-Approval
Chasing houses without pre-approval is like fishing without bait; the letter tells agents, sellers, and borrowers how much room they have.
A borrower with a 590 credit score, a solid paycheck, and low monthly bills still faces the rental-history hurdle. FHA never ignores the past, but the VA usually skips the formal Verbal Information Request, letting veterans slide without a landlord breathing down their necks.
Manual underwriting will kick in since the score is on the low end, and in the recent rent story, you crash in a hotel or bunk for free.-is shaky. Some underwriters would treat a long hotel stay as alternative credit if the room key were never more than a quick swipe.
An owner letter saying you lived rent-free still packs more punch, especially for that HUD-backed FHA stamp. A utility bill in the homeowner’s name can back it up, though it never seals the deal. Listing statements, bank statements, and anything else that proves the light stayed on at your address helps.
Borrowers can lift approval odds by waving in a chunky pile of reserves or showing they still have cash after the mortgage payment. Residual income calculations never hurt either, especially on a VA grant that expects service members to keep a cushion.
Buyers leaning this way are best off sticking with lenders specializing in low-score files. Those pros already know which boxes Congress and HUD let them bend.
Do you have a question about names or need more lender options? Please get in touch with me, and I can give you details and phone numbers that work.
-
Rent verification is normally required on manual underwriting FHA and VA files. However, if you cannot provide proof of rent, just write a letter of explanation stating that you live with your family to save money to buy a house. Rent verification is great and can be a strong compensating factor if the rental verification has low payment shock.
https://gustancho.com/when-is-rental-verification-required/
gustancho.com
When Is Rental Verification Required By Mortgage Lenders
When is rental verification required by mortgage lenders is when the file is a FHA or VA manual underwrite or if the lender has overlays on VOR.