Forums Discussions
-
Discussions tagged with 'FHA Manual Underwriting Case Scenario: Can Back-End DTI Slightly Exceed 50%?'
-
FHA Manual Underwriting Case Scenario: Can Back-End DTI Slightly Exceed 50%?
I’m working on an FHA purchase and would appreciate feedback from mortgage professionals, underwriters, or loan officers with experience in manual underwriting.
The borrowers are under contract to purchase a home in Orange County, Texas, and the FHA appraisal has already been completed.
The borrowers are strong candidates overall, but their main challenge is a high debt-to-income ratio caused by several factors in their file.
Borrower Profile
Both borrowers are full-time college professors.
One of the borrowers is also an ordained minister at a church with more than 400 members and has served in that role for approximately 11 years.
The church is supporting the borrower’s home purchase in two ways:
- The church is providing the funds needed for the down payment.
- The church has also agreed to provide a $2,500 monthly housing allowance for five years following the home purchase closing.
Both the housing allowance and gift funds are documented in a written agreement with the church, and we can provide supporting documents to the lender if needed.
The borrowers have a strong payment history, having paid about $2,899 in rent each month for several years.
Current FHA Loan Structure
The current transaction is approximately:
- Purchase price: $600,000
- Seller concession: $20,000
- Effective seller proceeds before other costs: approximately $580,000
- FHA base loan amount: $541,287
- Down payment: Gift from the church
The property itself also makes qualifying more challenging.
Annual property taxes are approximately $8,599.
Homeowners insurance is expensive, and because the property is in a flood zone, required flood insurance costs about $169 per month.
With higher taxes and insurance premiums, the total housing payment significantly affects borrowers’ qualifying ratios.
Current Debt-to-Income Ratios
Based on the current loan structure, the approximate ratios are:
- Front-end housing ratio: 28%
- Back-end debt-to-income ratio: 53.65%
ThThe front-end ratio looks reasonable. The main concern is the 53.65% back-end DTI. Why FHA Manual Underwriting Is Required
The file requires manual underwriting because one of the borrowers had a voluntary Chapter 13 bankruptcy dismissal approximately one year ago.
Because of the bankruptcy history and the need for manual underwriting, we can’t rely on a high DTI approval from the FHA TOTAL Scorecard.
The borrowers would prefer not to add their adult son as a non-occupant co-borrower.
If the deal can’t be structured with just the two borrowers, they are prepared to walk away from the purchase.
Possible Restructuring of the Purchase Contract
One option is to go back to the seller and try to renegotiate the deal.
The seller may potentially agree to reduce the actual sales price to approximately $550,000 while still providing a $20,000 seller concession.
The revised contract would therefore be structured as follows:
- Contract price: $570,000
- Seller concession: $20,000
- Effective price before other costs: approximately $550,000
The goal is to reduce the cash required of borrowers and possibly improve the loan structure.
The FHA case number and appraisal are already set. If the numbers work, the file can move forward once the FHA case is transferred.
The Main Underwriting Question
The main concern is whether an FHA manual underwriter has any flexibility when the back-end DTI is just over the standard threshold.
The current back-end DTI is approximately 53.65%.
In the past, I’ve seen FHA files approved with a back-end DTI above 50% if there were strong compensating factors.
This particular file has several potential strengths:
- Long-term, stable employment
- Two full-time professional incomes
- Approximately 11 years of additional ministerial employment
- Documented church housing allowance
- Gift funds from an established church
- Several years of documented $2,899 monthly rent
- Reasonable front-end housing ratio
- Established history of managing a substantial monthly housing payment. The question is whether these factors could support an exception when the back-end DTI is just a few points above 50%.%.
Other Possible Solutions I’m also looking for ways to lower the qualifying housing payment.t.Shop Homeowners Insurance
Texas homeowners’ insurance is significantly affecting the payment.I plan to shop the policy with several insurance carriers to see if the premium can be lowered. Even a small reduction in the monthly insurance expense could significantly improve the back-end DTI.I.
Interest Rate Buydown. Another option is to use part of the seller concession for discount points to permanently lower the interest rate on the loan.e.
The question becomes:
How much would the interest rate need to be reduced to bring the back-end DTI from approximately 53.65% to an acceptable manual-underwriting level? If the seller concession provides enough discount points to reduce the monthly principal and interest, this could be another way to make the deal work for the borrowers.
Review Treatment of the Minister’s Housing Allowance
The borrower will receive a documented $2,500 monthly housing allowance from the church for five years after closing.
The agreement is in writing.
Another key question is whether all or part of this housing allowance can count as qualifying income under FHA guidelines, provided it’s properly documented and meets FHA requirements for stability and continuity.
Questions for FHA Manual Underwriting Experts
I’d appreciate feedback on these points:
- Can an FHA manual underwriter approve a back-end DTI slightly above 50% when strong compensating factors are present?
- Would several years of documented $2,899 monthly rent serve as a compensating factor given the limited payment shock?
- Can a documented $2,500 monthly church housing allowance continuing for five years after closing be used as qualifying income?
- Would reducing the purchase price and restructuring the seller concession materially help this file beyond simply lowering the loan amount?
- Could seller-paid discount points be used to permanently buy down the interest rate enough to bring the DTI within manual-underwriting guidelines?
- Are there other FHA manual-underwriting strategies that might allow these borrowers to qualify without adding a non-occupant co-borrower?
- If the current lender cannot make the file work, would transferring the existing FHA case number to a lender experienced with FHA manual underwriting be a reasonable next step?
The borrowers really want this home. They have stable jobs, a strong rental history, and solid support from their. The challenge is finding a way to align the back-end DTI with the FHA manual underwriting requirements without adding another borrower to the loan. the loan.
One thing to check before posting: “homeowners insurance over $4,000 per month” seems unusually high. If you meant over $4,000 per year, I’d update that line before publishing.
View Last Reply:
replied 1 day ago
| Participants: 1 Member
|
1 Reply
