• Lisa Jones

    Member
    October 28, 2026 at 5:19 pm

    Great topic Elmoustahyl, Lenders usually don’t increase their DTI limits just because a state has high taxes or insurance costs. Instead, they include those higher expenses in your monthly housing payment when deciding if you qualify. This means with the same income and DTI limit, you’ll qualify for a smaller mortgage.

    Property taxes, the owner’s share of taxes, and any required flood insurance, mortgage insurance, and HOA dues all count, even if you pay them outside of escrow. When needed, the lender has to consider projected property tax reassessments, not just the seller’s current tax bill.

    For Fannie Mae loans, automated underwriting can allow a total DTI up to 50%. Manual underwriting usually caps DTI at 36%, or 45% if you meet certain other requirements. Each lender sets its own limits, so flexibility can vary not just by state, but also by lender and borrower.

    For example, if taxes and insurance are $500 higher each month, a borrower at the DTI limit will usually have $500 less available for mortgage principal and interest. The main thing to compare is the lender’s DTI ceiling and the actual tax and insurance amounts used to determine eligibility.

    https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/

  • Dustin Dumestre

    Member
    November 4, 2026 at 7:41 pm

    Honestly, no, lenders are not raising DTI limits for expensive states. They are just plugging the real tax and insurance numbers into the same payment, so the same income qualifies for less house than it did a few years ago.

    Where it gets interesting is that the ceiling is not the same on every program. FHA, VA, and USDA each handle this differently, and VA does not even use a single hard DTI cap the way conventional loans do.

    Which program are you looking at? The answer changes a lot depending on that.

    — Dustin Dumestre, Mortgage Advisor, F1 Lenders / NEXA Lending, NMLS #2145464. Educational only — not a rate quote or loan approval.

  • Elmoustahyi Abdallah

    Member
    November 4, 2026 at 9:12 pm

    Thank you both, Lisa and Dustin. This is exactly the kind of technical clarity I was hoping for.

    To answer your question, Dustin: I’m primarily looking at Conventional and FHA programs, as those are the most common for first-time buyers in high-tax states. The point about the “ceiling” being different for each program (FHA vs. VA vs. USDA) is crucial, and I think many buyers don’t realize that.

    Lisa, your example of the $500 difference in taxes/insurance directly reducing the loan amount by $500 is spot on. This is why it’s so important for buyers to calculate their “True Cost” (PITI + HOA + maintenance) before they even start house hunting.

    To help with this, I actually built a free, privacy-first calculator that lets buyers input their exact numbers (including estimated taxes and insurance) to see their real DTI and PITI before talking to a lender. No sign-up required, and it runs 100% in the browser.

    If you or your clients want to run the numbers, you can check it out here: https://smartmortgagecalc.space/true-cost

    I appreciate you both sharing this expertise. It’s helping a lot of buyers avoid these pitfalls.

Log in to reply.