• Insurance is nearly 10% of the average mortgage payment

    Posted by Ken Coury on October 28, 2026 at 1:09 pm

    Worth flagging from ICE’s September Mortgage Monitor: property insurance costs are still up 8.7% year over year, but the pace of growth is slowing sharply — the Q2 quarterly gain (1.8%) was the smallest since ICE started tracking it.

    The part that caught my eye: borrowers who shopped around and switched carriers cut their premiums by a record 6.6% — and got lower deductibles and more coverage than those who stayed put. Those who didn’t switch saw premiums rise 10.4%.

    Two takeaways from the insurance side:

    1. Insurance isn’t a footnote in affordability anymore. At 9.6% of the average monthly mortgage payment ($209/month on average, nearly 80% more than at the start of 2020), it’s a real line item in whether a payment works.

    2. Shopping the policy — not just the price — is what pays. The switchers didn’t just pay less; they ended up with better deductible structures and more coverage. That’s the difference between chasing the lowest premium and actually improving the policy.

    For anyone working files where the payment is tight: the insurance line is worth a second look before closing and at renewal. Sometimes the payment problem has an insurance answer.

    Source: ICE Mortgage Monitor, September 2026 — https://investingnews.com/ice-mortgage-monitor-property-insurance-costs-rise-8-7-annually-but-rate-of-growth-is-sharply-slowing/

    Curious — are you seeing insurance come up more often in your affordability conversations lately?

    — Ken

    Ken Coury replied 2 weeks, 5 days ago 3 Members · 4 Replies
  • 4 Replies
  • Julio Munoz

    Member
    October 28, 2026 at 4:35 pm

    Great topic, Ken. In the U.S., home insurance will typically add around $140- $260 per month to your housing payment. That’s not a fixed percentage of your mortgage. Matic’s 2025 data shows the average at $164 per month, with typical costs ranging from $140 for $200k-$300k of dwelling coverage to $258 for $800k-$900k of coverage. Those are just benchmarks, not a national range, so your actual cost could be more or less.

    So what proportion of your mortgage payment is that? For example, if your total monthly payment (including taxes and insurance) is $2,500:

    • $150 for homeowners insurance would be 6% of your payment.
    • $250 would be 10%.

    The actual % will be dependent on both your insurance premium and your mortgage payment. The insurance cost is based on your location, your rebuilding costs, your coverage limits and your deductible, not simply the amount you borrowed.

    How you pay for it

    If you have an escrow account, your lender will normally collect a portion of your annual insurance premium with each of your monthly mortgage payments and then pay the insurance company when the bill comes due. So if your annual premium is $2,400, you’d pay $200 a month towards insurance.

    Homeowners insurance is distinct from private mortgage insurance (PMI). Homeowners insurance is insurance on the house itself. PMI is insurance on the mortgage (i.e. it’s insurance for the lender). They can be two separate costs in your monthly payment.

    • Ken Coury

      Member
      October 29, 2026 at 2:36 pm

      Great addition, Julio — thank you. Your proportion example makes the key point better than the headline alone: the 10% is an average, not anyone’s actual number. Your percentage depends on both sides of the fraction — your premium and your payment — which is why two neighbors with similar homes can see very different shares. And the PMI distinction is worth repeating, because borrowers do mix those two up. Appreciate you adding the benchmarks here.

      — Ken

  • Ollie White

    Member
    October 29, 2026 at 3:38 pm

    Thank you, Ken. You pointed out an important detail that many homebuyers miss. While home insurance typically accounts for about 10% of a mortgage payment, the actual cost can vary widely from person to person.

    In mortgages, it’s common for borrowers to get pre-approved with an estimated HOEPA premium, only to find out the actual rate is much higher. This difference can increase monthly payments, change debt-to-income ratios, and sometimes even lead to a last-minute loan denial.

    This issue is hardest for FHA, VA, USDA, and conventional borrowers who are already near their debt-to-income limit. Even an extra $100 or $200 a month for homeowners insurance can push them over the limit and block loan approval.

    Homeowners insurance should be part of mortgage planning from the start, not something left until right before closing. Waiting can mean higher costs and fewer choices. If buyers compare policies, deductibles, and premiums early, they can avoid these issues.

    To my colleagues in mortgages and insurance: Are you seeing more borrowers have trouble qualifying for mortgages because of higher homeowners insurance costs? In some areas, has insurance become a bigger hurdle than property taxes?

    • Ken Coury

      Member
      October 29, 2026 at 5:46 pm

      Great point, Ollie — and the insurance side of it explains why this happens.

      At pre-approval, the file often carries the seller’s prior premium or a generic estimate. The actual premium isn’t set until the carrier does its own inspection and underwriting — roof age, rebuild cost, claims history, location — and if it lands higher, the monthly payment rises and DTI tightens. For borrowers already near their limit, exactly the FHA/VA/USDA/conventional group you named, there’s no cushion left. That’s how a file that qualified on paper gets squeezed late.

      The other version of the same problem shows up in year two: renewal increases get recalculated into escrow, and the payment jumps after closing. Same root cause — the premium was treated as a fixed number when it never was.

      On your taxes question, I’d frame it this way: property taxes are set and visible at pre-approval, so they rarely surprise anyone. Insurance is the moving part, and that’s what makes it the hurdle in the files where it bites. The fix is the boring one — get the quote and bind early, during the inspection period, so the real number is in the file before DTI is final, not discovered at closing week.

      For the LOs here — are you having to re-run DTI more often once the real premium lands?

      — Ken

Log in to reply.