-
Sellers Price Cuts and What Buyers Can Afford
GCA Mortgage Forums News for Wednesday, September 30, 2026: In today’s edition of GCA Mortgage Forums News, we will cover the widening gap between seller price cuts and what buyers can afford. This topic is timely, relevant nationwide, and offers a strong consumer angle following yesterday’s VantageScore 4.0 story.
GCA MORTGAGE FORUMS DAILY NEWS — Wednesday, September 30, 2026
In today’s edition of GCA Mortgage Forums News, we will cover the widening gap between seller price cuts and what buyers can afford. This topic is timely, relevant nationwide, and offers a strong consumer angle following yesterday’s VantageScore 4.0 story.
Topic of the Day: Home Sellers Are Cutting Prices as Mortgage Rates Push Buyers BackHome Price Cuts Surge as Mortgage Rates Rise Above 7%
- More U.S. home sellers are cutting asking prices as mortgage rates rise above 7%.
- See what September 2026 housing data means for buyers, sellers, and mortgage borrowers.
- This fall, it’s clear that buyers are harder to persuade, and sellers are starting to make changes.
- According to Realtor.com’s latest national housing report, over one in five homes for sale had a price cut in September.
- Meanwhile, mortgage rates rose above 7%, making it harder for buyers to afford homes and causing many to wait.
- This mix of more homes for sale, more price cuts, and fewer buyers is changing how negotiations work as we head into the last quarter of 2026.
September Home Price Cuts Reach Nearly Four-Year High
Realtor.com reported that 20.8% of active listings had a price reduction in September, up 0.9 percentage points from one year earlier. That was the highest share for any month since October 2022 and the highest September price-cut level since 2018. Price reductions were running above year-ago levels in all four U.S. regions and in 36 of the 50 largest metropolitan markets.
Housing Inventory is Also Moving Higher
Active listings increased roughly 5.5% from September 2025, bringing the number of homes available nationally above 1.16 million. Meanwhile, the number of homes under contract fell 4.1% from a year earlier. These numbers show that buyers have more options, but they remain cautious about making a move.
Higher Mortgage Rates Are Changing What Buyers Can Afford
The main challenge is still the monthly payment. Freddie Mac reported that the average 30-year fixed mortgage reached 7.03% for the week ending September 24, compared with 6.95% one week earlier and 6.30% during the same period last year.
Other daily mortgage rate measures rose even further by the end of September.
A buyer who qualified easily a few months ago might now need a lower price, a bigger down payment, help from the seller, a rate buydown, or a different mortgage to keep payments affordable. This is why a small price cut does not always fix the affordability issue.
Mortgage Applications Are Falling Along With Buyer Demand
Higher rates are already showing up in mortgage application activity.
The Mortgage Bankers Association reported that total mortgage application volume fell 6% for the week ending September 25. Purchase applications declined 4% from the prior week and were 14% lower than a year earlier. Refinancing activity dropped 9% for the week. :
This does not mean people have stopped wanting to buy homes.
It just means the finances have to make sense.
Today’s buyers have to juggle mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance, association fees, utilities, other debts, and daily expenses. A home might seem affordable at first, but qualifying can be tough once all costs are added up.
Buyers May Have More Negotiating Power This Fall
Buyers who are financially ready may find new opportunities in today’s market.
Price Is No Longer the Only Negotiating Tool
A seller who needs to close might be open to more than just dropping the price. Depending on the transaction and mortgage program, negotiations could involve:
- Seller-paid closing costs.
- Mortgage discount points.
- Temporary rate buy downs.
- Permanent interest-rate buy downs.
- Repair credits or completed repairs.
- Home warranties.
- Flexible closing dates.
Sometimes, a seller concession that lowers financing costs can help the buyer’s monthly payment more than a small price cut would. Borrowers should ask their loan officer to review the numbers before choosing the best option.
Sellers Need to Price Homes for Today’s Market
Sellers have a different challenge. A property priced according to last year’s conditions may sit while competing homes adjust their prices or offer concessions. September’s inventory numbers show buyers have more choices now than during the big shortages earlier in the decade. Sellers who really need to move may have to compete on price, property condition, incentives, and terms. This matters most in areas where the number of homes for sale has grown faster than the number of buyers.
What Homebuyers Should Do Before Making an Offer
In today’s market, getting fully preapproved is more important than ever. Don’t assume you should spend as much as you qualified for six months ago. Ask your mortgage professional to recalculate your payment using today’s rates, taxes, insurance, and any association fees.
If you don’t fit standard loan requirements, consider other options. FHA, VA, USDA, manual underwriting, jumbo, bank statement, DSCR, and other non-QM programs are designed for different needs. Choosing the right loan can be just as important as the price you negotiate.
GCA Mortgage Forums Bottom Line
September 2026 marks the start of a new conversation in the housing market. There are more homes for sale, more sellers are cutting prices, and buyers have more negotiating power in many markets. But affordability remains the deciding factor.
A $10,000 or $20,000 price cut might seem big, but higher mortgage rates can add hundreds of dollars to the monthly payment, offsetting those savings.
If you’re buying this fall, the best move is to look at the whole deal: price, mortgage type, interest rate, seller help, closing costs, taxes, insurance, and your monthly payment.
The headline may be that sellers are cutting prices. The bigger story is that buyers are making the housing market adjust to what they can truly afford. GCA Mortgage Forums Daily News provides mortgage and housing information for educational purposes. Mortgage guidelines, rates, qualification requirements, and program availability can change and may vary by lender and borrower circumstances. This gives today’s Daily News a new focus compared to yesterday. Yesterday was about VantageScore 4.0; today it’s seller price cuts, mortgage rates, and buyer leverage. It also sets up fresh topics for tomorrow rather than repeating the credit-scoring story.
-
3 Replies
-
In the current market, buyers have more bargaining power, but high interest rates are still the main barrier to affordability. Even though sellers are cutting their prices and providing incentives, these actions usually do not completely make up for mortgage rates which are near 7%.
Housing market snapshot
- Price cuts are occurring more and more often. In September, 20.8% of the listings that were active reduced their prices, which was the highest proportion for any September in Realtor.com’s records and 0.9 percentage points higher than the figure from last year. The number of homes on the market rose by 5.4% on a year-on-year basis to about 1.16 million.
- Because there are more houses on the market, the time it takes for properties to sell is longer, and there are fewer sales that are still pending; buyers now have more opportunities to haggle over price, closing costs, repairs, or have the seller pay for the interest rate reduction. Pending listings had a decline of 4.1% as compared with the previous year.
- The trend is not the same in all areas. In regions where there is a higher level of inventory—for example, in many parts of the Sun Belt and in certain areas of the West—there are more price reductions and seller incentives than in the more constrained markets found in the Northeast and the Midwest. Although national news offers some background, the local housing trends in your ZIP code are especially important at the moment.
For the week ending September 24, the average rate on a 30-year fixed mortgage was about 7.03 percent, the highest weekly rate since January 2025.
- A one-percentage-point rise in mortgage rates generally reduces purchasing power by around 10 percent. For instance, according to data from Realtor.com, a buyer who can afford a $500,000 house at 6 percent may be eligible only for a $450,000 house at 7 percent if they keep the same monthly payment. If the $2,000 per month paid on principal and interest is excluded, a 0.5-point change in the rate can affect purchasing power by about $30,000.
Although a price reduction may help, securing a good payment plan might offer greater benefits. For example, asking for seller credits to lower your interest rate or help with closing costs can reduce both your initial outlays and your monthly payments more effectively than a small price decrease. The effect will vary depending on the type of loan you have, the value of your home, and the amount of seller contributions allowed. Sellers can make the payments.
Buyers should:
- Pay by monthly installments, not just on the purchase price.
- Look at the seller’s price reductions compared with seller-paid buy-down or closing cost alternatives.
- Instead of sticking with one interest rate, keep a range of interest rates in your preapproval budget and use your stronger negotiating position to request inspections, repairs, and credits. You should still focus on your total payment, which will include taxes, insurance, and HOA fees, if applicable.
To sum up, buyers currently enjoy greater negotiating power, and lenders are placing more emphasis on payment plans. Sellers are providing extra incentives, such as price reductions, credits, and interest rate buy-downs. Yet higher borrowing costs still restrict affordability. Although more houses are available for sale and there is more room for negotiation, high mortgage rates remain a major obstacle.
-
Subject: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac now fully approve VantageScore 4.0—what lenders need to know
In a nutshell, the FHFA has instructed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to accept VantageScore 4.0 from all mortgage originators effective right away. This is not a change that will take place in the future—it is happening at this moment, and it makes it possible in a fundamental way to qualify borrowers who have previously been ‘credit invisible’ or have been penalized by the traditional FICO models.
What Just Happened
In July 2025, FHFA Director Pulte announced that VantageScore 4.0 would be put into immediate use for all mortgages guaranteed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Although the first instruction had allowed the industry until the fourth quarter of 2025 to make the switch, the new directive speeds up the process—thus lenders are (and should) begin using VantageScore 4.0 today.
Fannie Mae has already updated its Single-Family MBS disclosure files to include VantageScore 4.0 data, and the two GSEs are now accepting these scores from all lenders who originate loans.
Why This Matters for Your Pipeline
1. Thirty-three million additional borrowers who can be scored
VantageScore 4.0 can assign a score to about 33 million consumers who could not previously be scored using traditional models. These consumers include those with thin credit files, recent immigrants, and younger people who are building up their credit. For lenders who are dealing with first-time homebuyers or people with poor credit, this represents a major advantage.
2. Trends in the data make a difference
VantageScore 4.0 differs from classic FICO (which relies on a static snapshot) in that it looks at data over a period of 24 months that has been trended.
- Shows payment trajectory, not just current balance
- Gives rewards to people who are paying off their debt rather than those who are keeping high balances.
- Captures credit behavior direction—critical for post-pandemic credit recovery
Collection of payments for medical bills is no longer punished.
While classic FICO scores include paid medical collections when calculating the score, VantageScore 4.0 does not; this fact alone can make the difference between a borrower’s application being approved or denied if they have settled old medical debt.
4. Alternative Data Integration
The model uses rental history, payments for utilities, and telecom data where they are available—this is very beneficial for borrowers who have limited traditional credit.
Performance Validation
An independent analysis of 20 million mortgages found that VantageScore 4.0:
- Predicted 49% more pandemic-era defaults than Classic FICO (superior risk identification)
- Delivered a 20% lift in originations without adding incremental risk
- Correctly identified higher-risk loans when FICO scores were inflated
Operational Considerations
For Lenders:
- Ask your loan originator and your credit report provider—most of them have already incorporated VantageScore 4.0
- Update your adverse action notices and disclosures
- Train the LOs to decide when to use the VantageScore rather than the FICO (or both).
- Review investor overlays—some may still require FICO during transition
For Borrowers:
- Consumers with 620-660 FICO scores may see significant score differences
- People who are restoring their credit following a difficult period usually obtain a higher score on the VantageScore 4.0.
- Trended data rewards consistent payment behavior over time
My Take
It’s not merely a ‘new scoring option’ but rather a strategic move in the direction of more inclusive and predictive underwriting. For originators at Gustan Cho Associates and other firms dealing with non-QM and credit-challenged borrowers, VantageScore 4.0 provides them with another tool allowing them to say ‘yes’ when the traditional models would say ‘no’.
The companies that make the quickest adaptation will gain market share in the 33-million-person ‘credit invisible’ segment. The issue isn’t whether or not to adopt it—rather, it’s about how swiftly you can put it into operation.
Questions for the Forum:
- Has anybody begun to get both the VantageScore 4.0 and FICO? Is there a noticeable difference in the scores?
- Which LOS integrations are working well, and which ones are causing problems?
- Are investors currently accepting VantageScore 4.0 without the use of overlays, or are FICO requirements still in effect behind the scenes?
Please share your experiences from the field—let’s gather together the realities of implementation.
This article is provided for informational purposes and should not be regarded as legal or compliance advice. It is essential that you check the latest GSE and investor guidelines before making any changes to your credit-pulling procedures.
Want me to adjust the tone (more technical, more conversational) or add specific sections on compliance, pricing adjustments, or investor considerations?
-
This reply was modified 2 weeks, 6 days ago by
Bruce.
-
Please email me the credit and loan type.
Village Capital & Investment
***Times are rough with high rates. It always brings out some rougher credit situations. Well that’s were we can help you create some loans that are manuals. We do loans USDA,FHA,VA and Conventional. Send any and all scenario’s and I will do my best to assist.
Down to 500 Fico’s on FHA, no overlays we follow the guidelines.
NO MIN FICO on VA we have some flexibility on these so send scenario’s including BK’s that are over 12 months old with no derog after the BK. No overlays
Call me at 801-895-2593
Thanks
Ryon
Log in to reply.