-
Types of Mortgage Net Branch P & L Business Model
The mortgage industry is extremely competitive. Everything that can deter an NMLS-licensed mortgage loan originator from creating a book of business and developing a preferred third-party referral partner network from becoming successful is very difficult, BUT NOT impossible. I own, operate, and managed an independent mortgage net branch since 2015. The job of a full-time NMLS-licensed mortgage loan originator is tough enough and extremely competitive. However, if you are an independent mortgage net branch P and P owner under a larger mortgage broker or mortgage lender, it can be a challenging task where you need to realize the importance of every aspect of not just the mortgage loan origination process, which includes your support, operations, and licensed staff, in-house wage earners, third-party vendors, costs of running a remote or a brick and mortar branch, how the mortgage net branch markets to generate leads (whether it is buying leads, working with preferred referral partners, outreach, or using one or more of the many digital media marketing platforms). Marketing to attract consumers is the most important part of any business. No matter what type of business you are running, without customers, you will not generate revenue. Without generating revenues, you cannot pay your bills, expenses, and in-house and/or third-party business associates. There have been many changes on how mortgage companies operate and how they have restructured their compensation models in the past several years. Everyone knows how it goes right? One company has a brilliant idea on what and how they offer a MLO compensation and benefit program, and in no time you will see a bunch of mortgage company competitors all jump in to a similar business and compensation platform. For example, the mortgage net branch P and L model is not new and has been around for well over a decade. However, it was the mortgage bankers (direct lenders) that offered independent mortgage net branch business platforms. The targeted group of mortgage net branch were independent mortgage broker shops, high producing mortgage loan originators, MLOs who were team leaders at mortgage companies, and MLOs who had the drive, energy, and entreprenuer who wanted to take their mortgage loan originator to the next level. Once a larger mortgage lender started offering mortgage net branch opportunities, more and more companies from FDIC banks, to small, medium sized, and large direct lenders started aggressively offering similar Mortgage Net Branch P and L career opportunities. Remember, one thing. There is no such thing as free in the mortgage industry. Whether you are a consumer, borrower, loan officer, or a third-party professional inside or outside of the mortgage industry, the lenders, regulators, wholesale investors, government agencies, will nickel and dime you. There is a lot of money in the mortgage industry. When time are great such as with low rates, little to no inflation, a stable strong housing market, and a strong and stable economy, you can make substantial money in the mortgage and real estate industries. However, on the flipside, you can lose your ass off, lose your license, and shut down your doors. It is no secret that mortgage companies (direct mortgage lenders) were like hungry sharks trying to recruit mortgage loan officers, tam leads, and branch managers to their mortgage companies. What happened is the mortgage bankers offered they had the lowest rates and the best MLO compensation plan over the competition. They were like sharks. However, they were deceitful and liars. What happened imortgage companies were manipulating pricing on the back end. As direct lenders, lenders can adjust the back end fees and yield spread which reflects on the pricing of mortgage rates. If you have a lower back end compensation, that means the borrower gets a lower rate. It was an epidemic where every lender down the street and on the internet were suckering MLOs with doctored artificial rates and comp plans. Once you got sucked in to a mortgage company as a MLO or independent net mortgage branch, the first few months it was paradise. However, as time passed, you can obviously see rates were creeping up and your compensation as as MLO was plummeting. Eventually, it came to a point where direct lenders were pricing loans even to their best client’s at higher rates PLUS points over their competition. Even though the mortgage industry was extremely regulated, it did not stop greed. I remember, I lowered my compensation plan for my mortgage loan originators and myself when I was operating a net mortgage branch, however, I still had to charge discount points and my rates were substantially higher than a typical mom and pop mortgage broker. Mortgage Brokers generally have lower rates than mortgage bankers because the maximum compensation they can charge is a 2.75% yiield spread premium. Mortgage Bankers cannot survive with a 2.75% YSP cap because direct lenders have substantial higher overhead than mortgage brokers. Then in 2017, Mike Kortas and Mat Grella came up with a genius idea of creating and launhing NEXA Mortgage. Both Kortas and Grella were on a national campaign that Brokers were better. They came up withh a phenomenal marketing slogan that NEXA’s mission is to pay MLOs 100% and offer the lowest rate in the market with a network of 300 wholesale lenders and licensed in most of the 50 states. Due to the aggressive campaign and the RaRa of upbeating their MLOs, NEXA grew to close to 4,000 MLOs today. NEXA is still touting they have the best compensation in the mortgage industry and no other mortgage broker can beat them.
-
2 Replies
-
Mortgage Net Branch P&L Model: What MLOs Should Consider Prior to Joining a Mortgage Company
Discover operational details of the Mortgage Net Branch P&L Model, MLO compensation, costs of branch pricing, overhead, marketing, recruitment “offers,” and branch profitability.
An Overview of the Mortgage Net Branch P&L Model
The Mortgage Net Branch P&L Model provides experienced Mortgage Loan Originators (MLOs) with increased autonomy over business operations, compensation, staffing, and growth. However, higher compensation is accompanied by significant trade-offs.
Expenses such as branch costs, corporate fees, pricing, technology, payroll, compliance, marketing, and mortgage processing can substantially reduce the attractiveness of a compensation offer.
Therefore, before joining a mortgage company, MLOs should thoroughly evaluate the entire business model instead of focusing exclusively on commission rates.
Understanding the Competitive Nature of the Mortgage Industry
The mortgage industry has always been highly competitive. To succeed as a full-time, NMLS-licensed Mortgage Loan Originator (MLO), one must possess more than just technical expertise in loan structuring and closing. Securing borrowers is essential.
Without borrowers, there are no applications, no closings, and ultimately, no income. While this may seem obvious, it is one of the most important lessons I have learned in my career.
Since 2015, I have owned and managed an independent mortgage net branch. My experience demonstrates that loan origination is only one component of the business.
An MLO Must Also Consider:
- Lead gen
- Referral partners
- Marketing
- Loan ops
- Business ops
- Compliance
- Tech
- Payroll
- Licensing
- Staff
- Third-party vendors
- Office expenses
- Borrower retention
- DB management
- Reputation
- Recruiting
- Profit
An individual mortgage loan originator typically focuses on originating sufficient loans to sustain their income. In contrast, a mortgage net branch operator must manage all aspects of the business before, during, and after loan officer compensation.
This role presents a fundamentally different set of challenges.
Running a Mortgage Net Branch is Running a Business
Many seasoned loan officers mistakenly believe that becoming a branch manager automatically leads to a significantly higher income.
- This assumption is incorrect.
- A mortgage net branch operates as a business.
- Depending on the company’s structure and branch agreement, expenses may include salaries, payroll taxes, processing support, loan-origination systems, credit-report charges, technology, rent, office equipment, licensing, compliance-related costs, marketing, lead generation, insurance, accounting, administrative support, and numerous other expenses.
- Some expenses are covered by the corporate mortgage company, while others are charged to the branch or reflected in its profit-and-loss statement.
- The exact structure varies considerably from company to company.
- Therefore, MLOs evaluating a mortgage net branch opportunity should review the full profit-and-loss statement to accurately compare compensation structures.
- A higher gross compensation percentage does not always indicate a more profitable platform.
Marketing Is the Lifeline of a Mortgage Branch
Having the best processors, technology, loan programs, underwriting, and even experienced loan officers can set a branch apart from the competition. A mortgage branch cannot sustain itself without a steady flow of new inquiries. Effective marketing is essential for the success of a mortgage branch.
There Are Multitudes of Ways for a Mortgage Loan Originator to Drum Up Business:
- Realtor referral relationships
- Builders
- Attorneys
- Accountants
- Financial professionals
- Past clients
- Consumer referrals
- Purchased mortgage leads
- Organic search traffic
- Social media
- Video
- Email marketingCommunity outreach
- Networking
- Direct-to-consumer advertising
- Digital: Effective business generation strategies can vary significantly among MLOs.
- What works for one may not work for another.
- There are originators who build businesses that rely on a network of realtors.
- Others work on complex loan scenarios and earn referrals from other mortgage professionals.
- There are originators who work on leads from the web or work on search engine optimization.
- Regardless of the referral method, acquiring each customer involves a cost.
- These costs may include financial investment, time, marketing, advertising, technology, content creation, compensation, and commissions.
- A sustainable mortgage branch requires a reliable system for attracting borrowers.
What Creates a Sustainable Mortgage Business
A solid third-party referral network is an asset that can be valuable to an MLO’s business. Real estate professionals are careful not to damage their reputation by referring clients to untrustworthy loan officers. To gain the credibility needed to be referred by real estate professionals, an MLO must be dependable and proficient with communication, problem-solving, and interpreting loan guidelines.
That relationship is critical when the borrower does not fit the lender’s ideal loan scenario as determined by the lender’s automated underwriting system.
An MLO recognized for solving complex mortgage issues is likely to receive referrals from peers who are less focused on business growth. No single business model is inherently superior. MLOs should determine the type of mortgage business they wish to build before selecting a company to join. The mortgage net branch P&L model has become less prevalent and is considered outdated in recent years.
MLO Career Opportunities at Mortgage Bankers and Direct Lenders
Many mortgage bankers and direct lenders used branch opportunities to attract experienced mortgage professionals for whom the structure of their business is an important motivator.
The Ideal Candidates Were Typically:
- Established mortgage brokers
- High-performing MLOs
- Producing branch managers
- Mortgage teams
- Sales managers
- Loan officers with a strong business orientation
- This model remains attractive to prospective recruits.
- An experienced MLO, rather than operating as a sole business concern, can run a branch of the organization, hire staff, and grow a team and a brand at the local level.
- Furthermore, the MLO can influence the branch’s profitability.
- As similar models have been implemented by more mortgage companies, normal competitive business practices have been observed.
- Over time, similar compensation plans tend to emerge across the industry.
The Problem with the Compensation Number
- This is often where confusion arises in MLO recruiting.
- One company could promote a high basis-point compensation plan.
- Another company could offer a plan with 100% commission.
- Another company could promote a plan with low corporate margins.
- Another company could offer a plan with better pricing.
- Another company could offer leads, MLOs, processors, technology, health benefits, retirement benefits, or marketing support.
- Compensation figures in recruiting materials or advertisements are of limited value without clear context.
For Example, MLOs Should Know the Retention Per Closed Loan.
- What are the monthly and tech fees?
- Who pays for processing and credit reports?
- Are there compliance, payroll, and branch fees?
- Are there pricing differences among various investors?
- Are there different compensation structures for borrower-paid and lender-paid transactions permitted?
- What are the obligations for early payoffs?
- Who absorbs pricing concessions?
- Who absorbs the cures or mistakes?
- What is the process when a borrower requires an exception?
- These questions are often more important than headline compensation figures.
There is No Such Thing as Free in Mortgage
- Everything is compensated at the end.
- All mortgage professionals should understand this key principle regarding compensation plans:
- No service or resource in the mortgage process is provided at no cost.Processors need to be compensated.
- Underwriters need to be compensated.
- Compliance professionals need to be compensated.
- Technology is not free.
- Licensing and insurance have costs.
- Advertising, management, and accounting require payment.
- Office space must be paid for.
- Leads are not free.
- There is a cost to run a corporation.
- The issue is not whether a mortgage company incurs expenses.
- All companies incur expenses, as expected.
- The more relevant consideration is how these expenses are allocated and who ultimately bears the cost.
- Understanding the model clarifies why mortgage companies should not be compared based solely on commission rates.
Lending Officer Compensation vs. Mortgage Pricing
Here’s where immense confusion exists.
- Restrictions under Federal Regulation Z [12 C.F.R. § 1026.3(j)] specifically concern loan originator compensation.
- Simply, in most circumstances, compensation to a loan originator cannot be considered to have increased or decreased as a result of the loan’s interest rate, the loan’s Annual Percentage Rate (APR), or any other term of a loan that may be considered to be a restricted term.
- Federal regulations also restrict dual compensation, in which the originator is compensated by both the consumer and another party for the same transaction.
- The CFPB says mortgage loan officers and brokers can be compensated in various ways, such as salary, a set amount per loan, a set percentage of the loan amount, and/or a combination of the above, as long as the rules allow.
- This is important because loan officer compensation, company revenue, lender pricing, discounts, and the consumer’s interest rate are related but distinct concepts.
- There is no maximum compensation rate for Mortgage Brokers of 2.75%
- This is a figure I have seen repeatedly in my years in the mortgage industry.
- This figure can be cited, but it should not be cited as a Federal Law-sanctioned maximum compensation for mortgage brokers of 2.75%.
- One concept often mistaken for mortgage broker compensation is the Qualified Mortgage points-and-fees cap.
- For most Qualified Mortgages of $100,000 or more, the federal points-and-fees limit is 3% of the total loan amount.
- There are several limits that apply to smaller loans by dollar amount, and these limits are subject to regulatory changes, detailed calculations, and adjustments.
- Under certain conditions, loan-originator compensation may also be considered points and fees.
- The rules provide extensive information on what is included and excluded, and on the treatment of compensation.
This Does Not Mean:
- “Every mortgage broker is legally capped at 2.75% YSP.”
- I do not endorse this assertion.
Do Mortgage Brokers Always Have Better Rates than Mortgage Bankers?
No, mortgage brokers do not always have better rates than mortgage bankers.
There are numerous times that I have seen the wholesale broker channel provide much better pricing than the retail mortgage banking channel.
However, this does not guarantee that a mortgage broker will consistently offer better rates than a mortgage banker.
Mortgage Pricing is Influenced By:
- Loan program
- Investor
- Credit profile
- Loan-to-value ratio
- Property type
- Occupancy
- Lock period
- Market conditions
- Company margin
- Compensation structure
- Discount points
- Investor adjustments
- Pricing concessions
Mortgage Broker vs Lender
- One significant advantage of the broker model is the choice of lenders.
- A mortgage broker typically partners with several wholesale lenders, and a retail loan officer works through the lender hiring that loan officer.
- The CFPB provides a similar description, stating that mortgage brokers typically work with multiple lenders, whereas mortgage loan officers typically work at a single lender.
- Having many wholesale relationships gives a broker more opportunities to compare pricing and guidelines.
- However, having more lender relationships does not guarantee the lowest rates.
What I Learned About Pricing While Operating a Net Branch
This is where my experience differs, and I have a different perspective on mortgage company recruiting.
I have worked under compensation structures in which I reduced the compensation I paid to my loan officers and to myself to improve our competitiveness.
However, at times, the rates and costs to our borrowers remained, frustratingly, significantly higher than I considered competitive, compared with the pricing I observed with smaller independent mortgage brokers.
Operating your own branch provides a new perspective on the mortgage business.
You do not only consider your commission, but also:
What is the rate the borrower pays?
What is the cost the borrower pays?
Are we competitive with the other lender?
What is the margin between wholesale/secondary-market economics and the price offered to the consumer?
What is corporate retaining?
What am I retaining?
Why is my compensation structure making me uncompetitive?
At this point, even a well-designed compensation structure may become irrelevant.
Long-term profitability and sustainability are unattainable if attractive compensation structures result in pricing obstacles for borrowers.
Why Intense Recruitment Efforts
The primary reason is financial gain.
More specifically, productive mortgage loan originators (MLOs) generate greater revenue. That’s why established mortgage loan originators (MLOs) are more attractive as recruitment targets.
A loan officer with a persistent database, relationships, referrals, staff, and consistent monthly production is even more desirable.
This is why mortgage companies invest in attractive recruitment initiatives.
- More Attractive Compensations
- Easier Rate Access
- Greater Lender Access
- Superior Technology
- Superior Processing
- Superior Support
- Comprehensive Loan Products
- Faster Loan Closings
- Marketing Support
- Better Benefits
- Greater Autonomy
- Employer recruitment efforts are not the issue.
- The issue arises when an MLO joins a company based solely on recruitment efforts, without conducting a thorough personal assessment.
Never Join a Mortgage Company Based Only on the Rate Sheet You See During Recruiting
Pricing for experienced loan officers is one of the first things they analyze.
Pricing for Loans is a Snapshot. The Components of Pricing Can Change as a Function of:
- Time
- Loan Investors
- Markets
- Margins
- Compensation structures
- Investor relationships
- Strategic company direction
For this reason, I advise against evaluating a mortgage company based solely on a single rate comparison. Instead, compare multiple realistic loan scenarios.
Consider These Transactions:
- FHA purchase
- VA purchase
- Conventional purchase
- Conventional refinance
- Jumbo
- Low-credit borrower
- High-balance loan
- Investment property
- Non-QM loan
- Analyze the entire transaction.
- Review the rate.
- Review the points.
- Review lender credits.
- Review the adjustments.
- Review the compensation.
- Review the underwriting.
- Review the processing.
- Review the turn times.
- Review what the borrower receives.
- This analysis provides far more value than any recruiting presentation.
The Mortgage Banking Industry had Retail Loan Officers interested in Broker Loan Officer platforms with access, independence, and alternative compensation structures.
Competitors Saw the Changes
There was a disruption in the Mortgage Recruiting Industry.
The Meaning Behind “100% Commission”
- Mortgage Loan Originators need to understand the significance behind the phrase “100% commission.”
- In some cases, it can be a valid compensation structure.
- However, “100%” does not mean the Mortgage Company is operating at no cost.
- It is important to understand the context surrounding the “100%” statement.
Some of the Following May Occur:
- Transaction Fees
- Monthly Fees
- Fees for Technology
- Fees for Processing
- Administrative Fees
- Branch Fees
- Payroll Fees
- Corporate Fees
- Minimum Production Requirements
- Various Compensation Structures
- Early Loan Payoff Fees
- A 100% compensation structure is not inherently bad.
- For the right individual, it can be highly beneficial.
- Understanding the compensation structure is more important.
- Do not compare compensation rates between companies without understanding the net income generated by the same loan at each company.
- The net income is what truly matters.
Without Competitive Rates, Compensation Gets Meaningless
- Suppose Company A offers a compensation plan of 200 basis points, and
- Company B offers a plan of 150 basis points.
- Obviously, Company A looks more competitive.
- Yet, what if Company A’s borrower pricing is consistently […]
Support Staff Are Critical to the Success of a Mortgage Branch
The best of the best mortgage loan originators learn that there are limits to their capacity.
At a certain point, it becomes impossible to handle every borrower inquiry, manage employees, maintain referral sources, and oversee marketing and underwriting issues alone. Attempting to manage every aspect of the process is unsustainable.
Every successful mortgage operation relies on strong support staff.
A Good Mortgage Operation Would Have:
- Loan officer assistants
- Processors
- Contract processors
- Disclosure specialists
- Setup staff
- Underwriting support
- Compliance staff
- Closers
- Post-closing
- Marketing professionals
- Conversely, the lowest-cost company may not be the most profitable if significant time is spent on support tasks instead of originating loans.
Questions Every MLO Should Ask Before Joining a Mortgage Company
Before you go to another company and bring your license, team, clients, and branch along, make sure you get answers to the questions that are important to you.
- Compensation
- What am I compensated for?
- Which company deduction is taken before my payment?
- Are there monthly minimums?
- Are there per-file charges?
- What happens with early pay-offs?
- How do you manage pricing concessions?
- What do you charge on an FHA, VA, Conventional, Jumbo, and Non-QM loans?
- Can you show me live comparisons?
- How do you set your margins?
- Can you be more flexible with pricing?
- How do you manage exceptions?
- Lender and Investor Access
- How many lenders do I actually have access to?
- Which ones will I really use?
- Do I have access to specialty investors?
- If one lender cannot approve my borrower, then what?
Mortgage Underwriting
- Do you offer ‘manual’ underwriting?
- How do you escalate difficult loans?
- Can I speak with underwriting?
- What is the normal turnaround time?
- Does the company have lender overlays?
Mortgage Processing
- Is processing done in-house or outsourced?
- Who pays in this case?
- Can I use my own processor?
- What is the responsibility of the processor?
Compliance
- Who looked at the advertisements?
- How long does it take to get approval for marketing material?
- Who handles licensing issues for the state?
- How are branch examinations conducted?
- What compliance tasks does the branch take responsibility for?
Technology
- Which LOS do you use?
- What CRM do you provide?
- Is there an additional cost?
- Does the technology actually integrate with my workflow?
Marketing
- Does the company generate leads?
- Who keeps the leads?
- Who possesses my personal database?
- Can I market under my own approved brand or DBA, as the case may be?
- What happens to my database when I leave?
Employment and Exit Terms
- Are there ‘restrictive’ covenants?
- What happens to the loans in my funnel when I resign?
- What happens to unpaid commissions?
- Who owns branch-generated leads?
- What happens to employees associated with it?
- It is essential to review the contract directly.
- Exercise caution regarding information provided during recruitment. in recruiting.
- Exercise caution when moving a mortgage business that you built.
- Moving a mortgage business is relatively simple when you are an individual loan officer with no direct reports and a small pipeline.
- However, moving an entire mortgage business is a different undertaking.
You May Have:
- Employees
- Licensed MLOs
- Active borrowers
- Locked loans
- Relator partnerships
- Vendor partnerships
- Office agreements
- State licenses
- Advertising
- Web pages
- Phone services
- Email accounts
- CRMs
- Databases
- Pay
- Registered.
Therefore, a branch transition should be approached as a business decision. An attractive compensation plan alone should not justify moving your business to a new mortgage company. Mortgage markets change, and business models have to adapt to survive slow market years. The mortgage industry has good years and bad years. When rates are low, consumers are confident and make purchases. The reverse is also true. site is true. When rates start to rise, and consumer confidence is low, purchase transactions become practically non-existent. This is when the true nature of a mortgage business model emerges.
A Mortgage Business That Relies on Refinances May Struggle
An MLO without referral partners may have a business model that is not viable and may require adjustment. A strategy reliant on expensive purchased leads may become cost-prohibitive. Therefore, mortgage professionals should build their businesses to succeed in both favorable and challenging market conditions.
What Matters More Than the Best Compensation Plan
After years of operating my mortgage business, I believe that achieving stability and long-term competitiveness is more important than a high compensation figure.
I Want to Know:
- Can I compete for business?
- Can I close deals or loans?
- Are there answers from the processors?
- Can I reach management?
- Is the operation a trusted partner?
- Can the borrowers get better pricing?
- Can I build my business?
- Am I able to keep or retain loyal professionals?
- Do I have the opportunity to develop partnerships?
- Can the company survive a tough mortgage market?
- Can the branch remain profitable after all expenses? These questions are more significant than headline compensation figures presented during recruitment.
My Biggest Lesson From Operating a Mortgage Net Branch
Based on my experience, my primary advice to a loan originator considering a mortgage net branch is as follows:
The most important thing to consider should be the overall platform of the mortgage business being started, not compensation.
- Compensation is important.
- Pricing is important.
- Underwriting is important.
- Technology is important.
- So are the processors.
- Lender choice is important.
- Compliance is important.
- So is marketing.
- So is management.
- All of these factors must be considered collectively.
- I gained this insight through my experience operating a mortgage net branch.
- At times, I reduced my commission to secure better deals for borrowers.
- I often questioned whether the economics of a particular model were sound, especially when reviewing the P&L and realizing the compensation plan appeared very different in practice.
- That experience taught me a lesson that I use when evaluating mortgage lenders.
The Best Mortgage Company Depends on the MLO
Not every mortgage company can be the best for every loan officer. A new loan officer may need a lot of support, like training, leads, supervision, and a strong operating team. Compensation, pricing, and lender access may be more important to a high-producing self-generated loan officer. Recruiting and management tools may be important for a person who leads a team of loan officers.
A person who runs a loan officer branch may be interested in P&L, staffing, marketing, accounting, branding, and the branch’s long-term profitability.
A person who does manual underwriting may appreciate flexibility more than someone who does automated underwriting with high-credit, conventional borrowers. Understand your business thoroughly before selecting a platform. Selecting a highly regarded mortgage company may not align with your business approach if you lack a thorough understanding of your own operational needs.
Final Thoughts on the Mortgage Net Branch P&L Model
The mortgage industry faces many challenges, but it can be a very rewarding career. Thinking like a loan officer is not enough with the mortgage net branch P&L model. This requires adopting the perspective of a business owner. That includes knowing where the money is coming in, where the money is going out, what the borrowers are receiving, what the employees need, and whether the platform will hold up against competitors. I have had first-hand experience with developments in the mortgage industry while having my own mortgage net branch since 2015. I have learned enough to recognize that what is now the hottest compensation model will be old tomorrow.
- Things change.
- Model change.
- Things change.Markets change.
- Things change.
- People change.
- Your reputation and your book of business are harder to replace.
- Protect these assets diligently.
- Take responsibility, reTake responsibility, review all documents carefully, and ensure you fully understand their implications before signing or joining a Mortgage Net Branch or mortgage company.n really 100%?
- It could be 100% of whaIt may represent 100% of the compensation as defined by the company’s plan, but this does not guarantee the absence of additional costs.
- Before comparing compensation plans, MLOs should review transaction costs, monthly fees, technology expenses, processing fees, branch fees, early pay-off charges, and other related costs.
- Payment capped at 2.75% by the federal government?
- There’s no federal rule that sets the upper limit on mortgage broker compensation at 2.75%.
- Federal mortgage regulations include separate requirements for loan-originator compensation, points and fees on qualified mortgages, high-cost mortgages, steering, and dual compensation.
Can an MLO Earn Higher Compensation by Charging a Borrower a Higher Mortgage Rate?
In most cases, Federal Regulation Z prohibits compensation to loan originators based on the mortgage rate or any other prohibited terms.
Do Mortgage Brokers Always Have Better Terms Than Mortgage Bankers?
- No.
- While a broker may have an advantage since they can choose among several wholesale lenders, mortgage pricing depends on many factors, including the lender, investor, loan program, borrower, margin and compensation, market conditions, etc.
- MLOs and borrowers should compare the terms of individual transactions.
What Should an MLO Compare Before Changing Companies?
- Compare actual borrower pricing, compensation, lender access, underwriting, processing, technology, corporate fees, marketing, compliance, management, and the terms of the contract for what happens if they leave and the requirements for making a transfer.
Should I Join the Mortgage Company Offering the Highest MLO Compensation?
- Maybe, maybe not. The highest gross compensation could mean higher expenses, less competitive pricing, poor operations, limited loan programs, or weaker support.
- A better comparison is MLO expected net income, closing conversion, borrower competitiveness, and the ability to build a book of business.
Is Running a Mortgage Net Branch Worth it?
- If the MLO can bring in business, then maybe.
- If the mortgage broker is also prepared to take on the additional tasks of managing a branch, including running operations, compliance, marketing, and profitability, then it could be worth it for the mortgage broker.
- Running a mortgage branch is not the right choice for MLO’s looking to avoid the additional responsibilities of originating loans.
Author’s Note:
This guide is based on my own personal experiences in the mortgage industry and includes my own observations. I have provided links to industry business models or companies for context, but they are not meant to suggest any wrongdoing. Mortgage company compensation, pricing, employment, licensing, and branch structures vary based on the federal and state laws and agreements.
-
One part of this discussion that deserves more attention is the actual unit economics behind the branch.
A higher compensation percentage can look attractive while still producing worse economics for the branch.
Before changing a comp plan or adding another MLO, I think a branch should know at least four numbers:
• break-even production per MLO
• net contribution after compensation and support costs
• sustainable payout at the target profit margin
• EBITDA impact if production drops 15–20%Production alone doesn’t tell you whether a network is healthy. Two MLOs producing the same volume can have very different economic value depending on revenue rate, compensation and operating costs.
The interesting question isn’t just “How much does this MLO produce?”
It’s “How much does this MLO contribute after the full cost of supporting that production?”
Log in to reply.